sophia_sol: photo of a 19th century ivory carving of a fat bird (Default)
Sequel to last year's A Marvellous Light, a book I enjoyed but felt rather like it wasn't focusing on the story I wanted it to focus on. This one.... unfortunately continues the trend, though in a slightly different way.

Maud and Violet are two young women on a trans-atlantic ship voyage, who get caught up in a mystery surrounding a murder and a missing magical object. Together, they work to solve the mystery, accomplish their various goals, and navigate their growing relationship with each other.

There are many things to like about this, and honestly it is executed very well. There's good stuff between Maud and Violet, and the amount of trust and vulnerability they're a) interested in sharing with each other or b) capable of; and there's a fun cast of secondary characters in the restricted environment of a ship at sea. Some of the food descriptions really stuck with me, and I don't usually notice food in books! And we get to find out more about the Forsythia Club, the group of old lady magicians who had fascinated me so much in the last book.

But the story being told here is really a lot more hijinks-heavy a story than I usually prefer, featuring two main characters who are both hijinks-generators in their own ways, so I just wasn't really into the vibe for the first, like.... at least half the book.

And then I was teased with an AMAZING idea that then didn't go anywhere near what I was hoping and expecting for such an idea!

cut for spoilers )

At any rate, highly recommended for anyone more into hijinks than me. I really did like the characters and their relationship!

And the next book is going to feature my favourite secondary character from this book, apparently: Ross, the class-conscious pornography-smuggling reporter. I'll be interested to see where that goes! And I hope there'll be more of Mrs Vaughn in the next book.
sophia_sol: photo of a 19th century ivory carving of a fat bird (Default)
A delightful historical fantasy m/m romance novel! Set in the early 20th century, it features two men working together to figure out a) a dangerous and unfamiliar curse on one of them, b) what happened to the workplace predecessor of one of them, and c) what turns out to be some dangerous magic secrets that some nasty people are trying to get their hands on. Will they be able to work together and trust each other and fall in love? Signs point to yes.

I adore that this is a joyful mashup of several of my favourite things: queer people, historical fiction, fantasy, and a story unabashedly organized around the principles of how a romance goes. It kind of feels a bit like if the author was like "what if: jonathan strange and mr norrell sensiblities, but a romance novel approach" which, brilliant.

I greatly enjoyed the worldbuilding and the characters and the romance in this book, and I'm totally in to read any further books in the series which it's clearly setting up. BUT ALSO. The book puts all this effort into setting up how actually even though men are in control of what's generally understood to be the British magical world (and doing a poor job of it, compared to other magical traditions in other cultures), women turn out to be doing some really interesting and powerful and intellectually-rigorous work on magic, and yet the book is focused on men. Come on! I liked these specific men a lot, but the world is laid out to make me far more interested in what's going on with all the women! What I want is to read more about Flora Sutton her crew, and Mrs Kaur, and Adelaide Morrissey, and all sorts of other women who I'm SURE are doing interesting things that this book doesn't have space to explore. I hope the sequels will dig further into this!!!

Most Popular Tags

Page generated Jun. 20th, 2025 07:25 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios