sophia_sol: photo of a 19th century ivory carving of a fat bird (Default)
This quote from the introduction will give you a good idea of what one can expect from the book:

Dear Children:—You will like to know that the man who wrote these true stories is himself one of the people he describes so pleasantly and so lovingly for you. He hopes that when you have finished this book, the Indians will seem to you very real and very friendly. He is not willing that all your knowledge of the race that formerly possessed this continent should come from the lips of strangers and enemies, or that you should think of them as blood-thirsty and treacherous, as savage and unclean.


It's a book written in 1913 about the Sioux lifestyle written by a man who is himself Sioux, who was born in the mid-1800s. But written, as is understandable, from a very particular slant: to make the life seem approachable and acceptable to white people, to make them think more kindly of Indigenous people in the face of widespread prejudice. It definitely seems to me to romanticise things in places.

So it's an interesting look at one man's memories of what it was like to grow up Sioux in the 19th century (...I accidentally mistyped that at first as 29th century and I'd LOVE to read a book about that tbh!) but it probably needs to be taken with a few grains of salt in places.

It's a very episodic book, with each chapter being on its own theme or topic, and the chapters are mostly not connected to each other at all. Some chapters are more interesting than others, and I personally find that the chapters where Eastman's particularly talking about his own experiences are more interesting than the ones where he relates tales of other people. Probably what this means is that I should have instead read Eastman's memoir of his childhood, Memories of an Indian Boyhood, instead of this book but OH WELL this is the one that fell into my hands so this is the one I read.

(One detail in this book that amused me was his mention of young girls' playthings all being small versions of adult tools, and the girl with her little hide scraper happily helping her mother, and comparing it to the main character in The Birchbark House which I read earlier this year where the young girl haaaaates scraping hides.)
sophia_sol: photo of a 19th century ivory carving of a fat bird (Default)
These two books really read like one narrative that happens to be split into two parts. It's the story of one year in the life of a group of seven kids who spend all their time together that year. Five of them are siblings/cousins, one is a hired boy, and one is the neighbour girl.

There's no real overarching plot, just a series of incidents in their lives. The books do a good job of showing characters, and of writing believably about childhood. But the whole thing is suffused with a very strong theme of feeling nostalgia for a good time of life that is gone forever. And I found this theme pretty wearing!

I mean, based on what wikipedia says about the stage in LMM's life when she wrote these books, I understand why she'd write that theme, but it's not one that's calculated to appeal to me. Childhood was not a perfect golden time, and also I'm the sort of person who's much more inclined to live in the present rather than pine for a time gone by, whatever that time may be.

So overall these books just don't really work for me, even though I do care about the characters and their lives. Ah well!
sophia_sol: photo of a 19th century ivory carving of a fat bird (Default)
This book is a real diary written by a young woman between 1862-1865 (with most of the entries being in 1862-3), talking about her experiences in the US Civil War. Sarah kept her diary as a place to write all the thoughts and feelings that it wouldn't be appropriate for her as a lady to ever speak out loud. And it is fascinating.

Oh, it can get kind of tedious at times - a certain amount of repetition of sentiment, some occasional unclarity that makes it hard to follow exact events, and a huge cast of characters it can be hard to keep straight and who she doesn't always bother to properly introduce/explain. But overall Sarah writes very well, and as a look into the thoughts of a Southern girl living through the war, it is very compelling.

Read more... )

Most Popular Tags

Page generated Jun. 12th, 2025 11:42 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios